By Jaime Jo Wright
Have you ever tried to outrun your past, only to realize it doesn’t stay behind you… it follows you in ways you never expected? And sometimes it doesn’t even show up as the past at all – it shows up as your present, and maybe even your future.
This book sits right in that space.
Tropes
Let’s start with the basics:
- Dual timeline
- Haunted / “living” house
- Cold case mystery
- Gothic small-town setting
Themes
This story leans into some heavy, meaningful ground:
- Grief
- Trauma recovery
- Female resilience and strength in hardship
Synopsis
Two women, separated by a century, find themselves connected through one place: Foster Hill.
In the early 1900s, Ivy Thorpe carries deep grief after the loss of her brother and the betrayal of someone she trusted. When a body turns up near a local estate, she steps straight into a mystery filled with buried secrets and long-hidden truths.
In the present day, Kaine Prescott runs from a life she can no longer face in San Diego. She buys the rundown Foster Hill with the hope of restoring it in honor of her late husband. Instead, she finds a house that refuses to stay quiet. What she uncovers ties directly into the danger she thought she left behind.
As past and present begin to collide, both women move toward one conclusion – one that exposes secrets that never should have stayed buried.
My Thoughts
Jaime Jo Wright does it again.
I found this book even more haunting and intense than The Bookshop of 99 Doors. I had to set it down more than once just to clear my head. The haunting never crosses into horror – it stays eerie, atmospheric, and deeply unsettling in the best way.
The house absolutely acts like a character. I love when authors do that. Foster Hill holds layers of secrets, and each one peels back like an onion. Every reveal pulls you deeper into the story until you realize how far in you’ve gone.
Both Ivy and Kaine feel fully developed. As they untangle the mystery, they also confront parts of themselves they’ve avoided. Their growth feels natural and earned.
The romance stays closed-door and clean, with no spice or language, which fits the tone of the story well.
Faith threads through the book in a grounded way. It never feels forced. Instead, it shows up in the real, messy moments – grief, anger, questioning, and that very human tension of trying to trust God in the middle of loss.
And the pacing? Excellent. I read this in under 48 hours because I kept telling myself, “just one more chapter,” until suddenly I was too far in to stop.
I love finding stories like this – haunted, atmospheric fiction with a strong faith undercurrent done well.
Cozy Vibes Check
Atmosphere:
Gothic, eerie, and wrapped in quiet tension from beginning to end.
Pacing:
The story builds both timelines carefully, letting each layer of the mystery unfold at its own pace.
Emotional Tone:
Reflective, somber, and unsettling at times, but threaded with quiet hope.
Reading Experience:
It felt like peeling back old wallpaper in a forgotten house and finding something hidden underneath that was never meant to be seen.
Favorite Quote
“Sometimes the past doesn’t stay buried… it waits for someone brave enough to listen.”
Pair It With
Drink: Hot chai tea – something warm that carries both comfort and quiet courage in the same cup.
Vibe: A steady Sunday morning rain with the windows cracked just enough to let the sound in – the kind that becomes part of the story. Percy at my side, a light summer blanket pulled close, and that quiet feeling that the house outside your window feels a little too still.
Rating









